Intersect Committees
Intersect Knowledge BaseIntersect Website
Intersect - Product committee
Intersect - Product committee
  • ABOUT
    • Cardano Product Committee (CPC)
    • Committee Members
    • How to Join or Contact Us?
    • Product committee focus
  • Committee outcomes
    • 2025 Cardano's roadmap
      • 2025 Proposed Cardano Goals
      • 2025 Proposed Cardano Roadmap
        • 2025 Proposed Cardano Roadmap - Japanese translation
        • 2025 Proposed Cardano Roadmap - Spanish translation
        • Roadmap consultation and contribution process
    • 2025 Proposed Research Budget
    • 2030 Long-Term Cardano Vision
      • Help us collect insights
        • Run one of the Cardano Vision Creation workshops
        • Get sponsored to run a local gathering or a session with a business
      • Insights collected
        • Insights collection workshops
          • Workshop - 9th March 2025 - Japan
          • Workshop - 13th March 2025 - Remote
          • Workshop - 29th March 2025 - Remote
          • Workshop - 11th April 2025 - Paris
          • Workshop - 15th April 2025 - Remote
          • Workshop - 23rd May 2025 - Remote
        • Focus groups
          • SPOs - focus groups
            • Focus Group - SPOs - 26th March 2025
            • Focus Group - SPOs - 3rd April 2025
        • Survey
    • Product committee site
  • Committee meeting notes
    • 2025
      • 27th May 2025
      • 20th May 2025
      • 13th May 2025
      • 6th May 2025
      • 29th April 2025
      • 22nd April 2025
      • 15th April 2025
      • 8th April 2025
      • 1st April 2025 (with Intersect Board)
      • 25th March 2025
      • 18th March 2025
      • 11th March 2025
      • 4th March 2025
      • 27th February 2025
      • 20th February 2025
      • 13th February 2025
      • 6th February 2025
      • 30th January 2025
      • 23rd January 2025
      • 16th January 2025
    • 2024
      • 19th December 2024
      • 12th December 2024
      • 25th November 2024
      • 21st November 2024
      • 14th November 2024
      • 7th November 2024
      • 31st October 2024
      • 24th October 2024
      • 17th October 2024
      • 10th October 2024
      • 3rd October 2024
      • 26th September 2024
      • 19th September 2024
      • 12th September 2024
      • 10th September 2024
      • 5th September 2024
      • 29th August 2024
      • 7th August 2024
  • Working Group
    • Core Infrastructure Roadmap working group
      • Core Infrastructure Definition
      • Process Flow
      • Current State
        • List of Inflight items (2024)
      • Roadmap Items (Proposals for 2025 onwards)
        • In Cycle
        • Triage
        • Refinement
      • Working Group members
      • Internal Communication Plan
      • Working Group Milestones and meeting schedule
        • (22/4/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (29/4/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (7/5/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (13/5/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (20/5/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (28/5/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (3/6/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (10/6/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (17/6/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (25/6/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (1/7/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (8/7/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (15/7/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (22/7/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (29/7/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (5/8/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (12/8/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (19/8/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (27/8/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (2/9/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (9/9/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (16/9/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (23/9/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (30/9/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (7/10/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (14/10/24) Meeting Minutes
        • (21/10/24) Meeting Minutes
      • Working group FAQ
      • Glossary
    • Special Interest Groups
      • Interoperability
      • Scalability
      • DeFi/DApps
      • Stake Pool Operators
    • Research Working Group
  • Standards operational procedures
    • Chair Election Process
    • Chair Rotation rules
Powered by GitBook
On this page
  • Data Points
  • Key Learnings
  • 🏗️ Infrastructure & Operations Challenges
  • 🗣️ Communication & Community
  • ⚖️ Protocol Parameters & Incentives
  • 🏛️ Decentralization & Resilience
  • 🕸️ Stake Handling
  • 💼 Business Opportunities for SPOs
  • ⚙️ Technical Improvements
  • 💰 Payment Infrastructure
  1. Committee outcomes
  2. 2030 Long-Term Cardano Vision
  3. Insights collected
  4. Focus groups
  5. SPOs - focus groups

Focus Group - SPOs - 26th March 2025

PreviousSPOs - focus groupsNextFocus Group - SPOs - 3rd April 2025

Last updated 3 days ago

Data Points

Key Learnings

🏗️ Infrastructure & Operations Challenges

  • Infrastructure costs are a constant challenge, especially for smaller/new SPOs.

  • Delegation is sticky; it’s hard for new or small pools to attract and maintain delegators.

  • ISPO mechanisms can distort delegation and harm network sustainability.

  • Cloud reliance is high — 90%+ of nodes run on cloud services, creating centralization risks.


🗣️ Communication & Community

  • Need for improved communication between SPOs and IO/engineering teams.

  • More consistent updates and clearer communication channels desired.


⚖️ Protocol Parameters & Incentives

  • The minimum pool cost disproportionately penalizes smaller pools.

  • Suggested dynamic adjustment of minimum pool cost linked to ADA price.

  • Support for community voting on both minimum pool cost and minimum margin.

  • Concerns about the “race to the bottom” in fees and its impact on network health and geographic stake distribution.

  • Multiple protocol parameters flagged for adjustment: min pool cost, min margin, K parameter, tau, and rho.


🏛️ Decentralization & Resilience

  • Cloud concentration is a major decentralization risk.

  • Additional infrastructure needed for dApp processing to avoid central points of failure.

  • Alternative Cardano node implementations are in development but years away from maturity.

  • Multiple node versions increase attack surface — rigorous testing is essential.

  • Potential risks of combining Midnight and Cardano nodes on the same hardware need careful management.


🕸️ Stake Handling

  • Retired pools can create inefficiencies and challenges for chain density and stake management.

  • Automating reassignment of stake from retired pools is legally and technically complex.

  • Ideas like staking baskets or delegation tools could help improve stake distribution.


💼 Business Opportunities for SPOs

  • Running infrastructure for sidechains (Hydra heads, Midgard validators, Midnight nodes).

  • Exploring partnerships with new projects and DeFi initiatives (BTC bridge, Encoins privacy tech).

  • Transaction prioritization services could become an additional revenue stream.

  • SPOs well-positioned to provide critical infrastructure services beyond standard block production.


⚙️ Technical Improvements

  • More flexibility and transparency needed in node versioning/testing.

  • Discussion of running real-time optimized Linux distributions.

  • Concerns about bugs in the networking layer — importance of community contributions in testing and reporting.


💰 Payment Infrastructure

  • Direct fiat on-ramps would improve user experience and encourage network use.

  • Increasing transaction volume (e.g. via BTC bridge) seen as a way to sustainably increase rewards.

Session recording
Transcript
Notes