Project Incubation Lifecycle Framework
INTERSECT
Project Lifecycle Framework
Draft, v0.1
In attn OSC / June 10, 2024
As Cardano’s journey in the Voltaire era continues, the Open Source Committee’s strategy empowers community-led and sustainability-driven decisions, shaping our path forward in open source development
General Context
This document defines and details the Intersect’s Project Lifecycle Framework. It is specifically developed to implement the strategic directives outlined in the Open Source Strategy adopted by OSC on June 7, 2024.
This framework introduces a structured approach for projects, from inception to potential sunset. Each stage of a project’s lifecycle — Incubation, Growth, Maturity, Decline, and Abandonment — is aimed to be aligned with Cardano’s commitment to open source development, technological excellence, and community empowerment.
The development of this lifecycle framework is a response to the need for a dynamic management tool that adapts to the evolving requirements of projects. It has been crafted through a collaborative effort involving diverse stakeholders, ensuring that it not only supports projects in achieving their individual objectives but also contributes to the broader goals of the Cardano community.
By referencing the strategic pillars outlined in the OSC’s Strategy for Cardano Open Source initiatives, this framework ensures consistency in approach and alignment with Cardano's mission and vision. It offers a detailed, action-oriented guide that complements the strategic document, focusing on the practical aspects of project management, monitoring, and evolution within a structured lifecycle context.
In essence, the Project Lifecycle Framework is designed to operationalize the strategic insights from the OSC strategy document, providing a clear, actionable path for managing the lifecycle of projects. It embodies our commitment to fostering sustainable project development and ensuring that every initiative under the Cardano umbrella is equipped to thrive in an ever-changing technological landscape.
Summary
The Project Lifecycle Framework designed for the Open Source Committee Cardano is a strategic tool aimed at managing the evolution of projects from their inception through to their maturity and potential sunset. This framework provides structured guidance through defined stages: Incubation, Growth, Maturity, Decline, and Abandonment. Each stage is equipped with specific goals, criteria, actions, and metrics to ensure that projects not only thrive but also align with the broader objectives of sustainability and community leadership inherent to Cardano's philosophy. By implementing this framework, we aim to enhance project outcomes, foster robust community engagement, and ensure the long-term viability of initiatives within the Cardano ecosystem.
Incubation
Stage Definition
This is the initial phase of a project, characterized by setting up the foundation and infrastructure necessary for future development and growth. Projects in this stage typically have early stage (or even no) codebases, minimal documentation, and a small number of contributors (1-3 usually).
Criteria
New or newly forked project with minimal active codebase
Few or no active contributors
Limited documentation and testing resources
Initial stages of community development
Goals
Establish a clear project vision and roadmap
Build a foundational technical infrastructure
Attract initial contributors and establish a user base
Actions
Establish project vision and roadmap - develop a clear and concise vision statement and a roadmap that outlines the project’s objectives, expected milestones, and timelines.
workshops with stakeholders
SWOT analysis to understand strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats
Community formation - develop community guidelines, set up communication platforms (like Matrix/Discord channels), and actively engage with early users and contributors
community engagement
introductory webinars, Q&A sessions.
Build technical foundation - start with a solid technical setup, including a well-structured code repository, basic documentation, and initial testing frameworks.
version control, CI/CD tools
security framework - Security Council spinning up.
basic documentation tools - contributing guide vs wiki, etc
architecture help and/or boilerplate
Initial marketing and outreach - implement initial marketing strategies to attract contributors and users, such as blog posts, introductory videos, and participation in relevant tech communities
marketing toolkit: logo, branding, social media templates
tech conferences
Feedback mechanism setup - establish a system to gather feedback from early users and contributors to refine project direction and community interaction.
feedback forms
community meetings
direct communication channels
Developer Advocates
Monitoring and Evaluation
Metrics: number of active contributors, frequency of code commits, community engagement levels, completion of roadmap milestones.
Regular review: schedule monthly reviews to assess progress against the roadmap and adjust plans as necessary based on feedback and initial outcomes.
Growth
Stage Definition
Growth stage is characterized by a significant increase in activity around the project. The project gains traction with a growing number of contributors and users. It requires stabilization and normalization in infrastructure, processes, and community management.
Criteria
Increasing number of active contributors and users
Expansion of the codebase and improvement in feature set
Noticeable activity in terms of commits, pull requests, and community engagement
Revenue or adoption
Goals
Manage scalability to accommodate increasing demands
Enhance infrastructure to support growing user base and contributor activity
Maintain and improve the quality and stability of the project
Actions
Scale infrastructure - upgrade technical infrastructure to support increased loads and more complex project demands
Enhance documentation and support - expand the documentation to cover new features and use cases thoroughly. Improve support channels to handle the growing number of inquiries and contributions efficiently
Implement more advanced testing and QA - develop more comprehensive testing frameworks to ensure the stability and quality of the project as new features and updates are rolled out
Community development and engagement - enhance community management strategies to grow and support a vibrant, engaged, and collaborative community
community management tools
regular community events
recognition programs for major contributors
Implement governance framework - clear governance structures to ensure that decision-making keeps pace with project growth and that all stakeholder voices are considered
governance frameworks
regular community meetings for decision-making
transparent voting systems.
Monitoring and Evaluation:
Metrics: growth in contributor and user base, response times to community inquiries, uptime and performance metrics, frequency and impact of new releases.
Regular review: conduct quarterly reviews to evaluate the effectiveness of scaling efforts, infrastructure upgrades, and community engagement strategies
Maturity
Continuing from Growth, the next critical phase in the Project Lifecycle Framework is the Maturity stage. This stage is characterized by the project having established a stable and active community, a solid technical foundation, and achieving broad recognition in the industry.
Stage Definition
At this stage, the project is well-established, with stable releases, a loyal user base, and a robust contributor community. It is recognized for its reliability and is a go-to solution in its domain. Also it is self sustainable.
Criteria
Large and active community with diverse contributors
Stable and reliable codebase with regular and predictable release cycles
Broad adoption and recognition within the industry
Effective management of community dynamics and conflicts
Goals
Maintain momentum and motivation within the community and contributor base
Manage conflicts and disagreements effectively to sustain community cohesion
Ensure the long-term sustainability and viability of the project
Actions
Continuous improvement and innovation - keep the project technologically relevant and innovative, integrating new trends and feedback.
Sustain community and contributor engagement - iImplement programs to recognize contributions, provide continuous learning opportunities, and keep the community engaged
annual community events
contributor rewards programs (contributor of the year/month)
Conflict resolution mechanisms - develop and refine conflict resolution strategies to handle disputes and disagreements within the community effectively
Long-term viability planning - plan for future challenges and opportunities to ensure the project remains viable and relevant
Leadership and succession planning - develop a clear succession plan for key project leaders to ensure continuity and stability
leadership development programs
mentoring and shadowing
transparent leadership selection processes
Monitoring and Evaluation
Metrics: Contributor retention rates, frequency of community conflicts and resolutions, user satisfaction ratings, rate of innovation adoption.
Regular Review: Conduct bi-annual strategic reviews to assess the project's alignment with long-term goals and industry standards.
Decline
Transitioning from the Maturity stage, the Decline stage might follow in the Project Lifecycle. This phase is characterized by a gradual reduction in activity, community engagement, and innovation, which if not managed properly, can lead to stagnation or eventual abandonment of the project.
Stage Definition
In this stage, the project experiences a decrease in active contributors, slowing innovation, and potentially reduced user interest. This might be due to technological reasons, competitive alternatives emerging, or a shift in community interests.
Criteria
Noticeable decrease in the number of active contributors and users
Reduced frequency and impact of updates and new releases
Challenges in maintaining community engagement and enthusiasm
Increasing difficulties in managing the project and sustaining its operations
Goals
Identify and address the underlying causes of the decline
Revitalize the project if possible, or manage its decline in a way that preserves its legacy.
Ensure a smooth transition for users and contributors if the project is to be sunset
Actions
Conduct a thorough assessment - analyze the reasons behind the project's decline, including technological assessments, competitor analysis, and community feedback
Revitalization initiatives - depending on the assessment, implement initiatives aiming for project revitalization: rebranding, integrating new technologies, or pivoting project goals
Plan for sunset transition - iIf revitalization is not possible, plan for a structured sunset of the project that considers the needs of current users and the community
Preserve legacy and knowledge - ensure that the valuable outputs of the project (e.g documentation, codebase) are preserved and remain accessible to benefit future projects or historical reference.
Monitoring and Evaluation
Metrics: trends in community activity, project update frequency, user feedback and satisfaction
Regular review: quarterly reviews to monitor the effectiveness of revitalization efforts or manage the decline process
Examples
Imagine a project in the field of DeFi that has entered the Decline stage due to newer technologies. Actions might include:
Hosting a series of community brainstorming sessions to explore potential new directions for the project
Developing a partnership with educational institutions to use the project as a teaching tool, providing a new avenue for utilization
Creating a detailed archive of the project’s development history and major achievements to serve as a resource for future developers
Abandonment
The final phase in the Project Lifecycle Framework is the Abandonment stage. This stage is reached when a decision is made to officially end active development and support for the project. Although it marks the end of active project lifecycle, managing this stage effectively is important to ensure a respectful and strategic closure.
Stage Definition
Abandonment stage occurs when a project is officially retired or abandoned. This equals no further development, support, or maintenance planned. The project may still be used or referenced, but it no longer evolves.
Criteria
Official decision to stop development and support
No active contributors aboard
Minimal to no user engagement
Legacy code and documentation remain available, but are no longer updated
Goals
Ensure a smooth transition for users and contributors to other solutions or projects
Preserve the project's legacy and contributions for the community’s benefit
Minimize negative impacts on the community and Cardano’s image
Actions
Communicate decisions transparently - clearly communicate the decision to abandon the project to all stakeholders, explaining the reasons and outlining the next steps
Communicate the project's achievements - compile and publish documentation of the project’s history, key achievements, and impact.
Preserve code / repos - ensure that all code, documentation, and other resources are archived in an accessible format for future reference
Celebrate the project - organize an event or create content to celebrate the achievements of the project and its community, acknowledging the contributions of everyone involved
Monitoring and Evaluation
Metrics: effectiveness of communication about the abandonment, user satisfaction with provided transitions, accessibility of preserved materials.
Review: post-abandonment checks to ensure all documented resources are maintained and accessible, and feedback from the community is addressed
Examples
An example could be a scenario where a project focused on a specific framework is being abandoned due to the emergence of another, more modern technology. Actions could include:
Hosting a final webinar to discuss the project’s timeline, its impact, and to thank the community
Collaborating with a technology education nonprofit to preserve the project’s outputs as educational materials
Setting up an open archive of all project materials, ensuring that the knowledge isn't lost.
By thoughtfully managing the Abandonment stage, the project can conclude on a positive note, ensuring its contributions are recognized, and the community is respectfully transitioned to new opportunities. This careful closure not only respects the legacy of the project but also maintains trust and goodwill among the Cardano’s watchers.
Last updated
